Scanner Buying Guide

Scanner Buying Guide

Last Updated: 09/27/2007

The Basics: Scanners

A scanner's job is simple: It converts a physical photo or document into a digital version that you can manipulate on your computer. Scanners are great for archiving old photographs in a digital format that will never fade, converting print documents into digital word processing files that can be edited and even compiling and organizing business cards. At their core, scanners haven't changed much over the years, but they've become much more refined devices, capable of crisp and accurate reproductions.

Most scanners are traditional flatbed models with a large footprint. While these can occupy a considerable chunk of desktop real estate, the design makes it easy to flip up the lid and scan even legal-size documents. Flatbed and photo scanners used to be separate devices, with the latter being much smaller and offering higher resolution and color depth to handle photographs. However, specifications for flatbed scanners have increased while the cost has stayed the same, and most new photo scanners are simply high-resolution flatbeds.

Sheet-fed scanners are small models that feed a document or photograph through the thin, compact body of the scanner to capture an image. These are less popular than they were a decade ago, but they're still around. Sheet-fed scanners are more portable, but they don't usually have the same resolution or versatility of the full-size flatbed scanners.

Speaking of portability, pen scanners have become more prevalent in recent years. These scanners can either scan text one line at a time or, in some of the newer models, scan entire documents or images in a single pass. They're extremely easy to carry around, but you need a steady hand to capture an accurate image.

The power of a scanner is in its optical resolution, rated in dots per inch (dpi). Most new flatbed scanners offer resolutions of 2,400 dpi or higher, which means that you'll be able to recreate a photograph accurately. The specs on the scanner box also talk about color depth or bit depth. This number refers to the amount of color that can be added to each pixel of an image. Greater color depth means more realistic images, and most new scanners offer color depths of 24-bit or higher (currently up to 48-bit).

One thing to keep in mind with scanners is that creating high-resolution scans consumes a lot of resources, including hard drive space. If you're going to be scanning numerous full-size images, make sure you've got a computer with the power and the space to handle them.

 

How to Shop

Obviously, the kind of scanner you should buy depends on your scanning needs. If you have a variety of items that you will be scanning, it's best to go with a traditional flatbed scanner. Most flatbeds have adjustable lids that let you scan 3-D items such as magazines, bound books and other objects. They usually have the highest optical resolutions, so you'll be able to create the sharpest scans. And they're often less expensive than non-traditional scanners.

However, not all flatbeds are created equal. Budget flatbed scanners have maximum image sizes of 8-1/2x11-7/10 inches, which is large enough to scan letter-size documents. If you need to scan legal-size documents, you'll want to spring for a flatbed scanner with a larger scan area of 8-1/2x14 inches.

Flatbed scanners aren't for road warriors, as their design requires them to stick close to a desktop computer. If you've got scanning needs attached to your portable computer, you'll want to take a look at a sheet-fed or pen scanner. Some sheet-fed models use new low-power CIS (Contact Image Sensor) technology and don't require an external power source. They get their power through a USB connection, so that's one less accessory to pack. Pen scanners may not offer as high of optical resolution as flatbed scanners, but they're extremely portable.

Once you've settled on a category of scanner, you can start looking at the extras. Many flatbed models offer an optional transparency adapter, and some even have one built in. This add-on device lets you scan in film negatives and slides, creating full-size images from your small originals. If you're going to be archiving a lot of old photo negatives, a transparency adapter (or at least the option to add one in the future) is a must.

Some flatbed scanners ship with automatic document feeders (ADF). If you perform a large volume of scans, an ADF makes it easier to stack up photos or documents into a tray that then feeds them into the scanner one at a time.

Other scanners have quick-use buttons that let you quickly perform an action, such as e-mail an image, send it to a printer to make a copy or create an Adobe Acrobat PDF document from your scan. These can be handy for quick tasks, saving you the time to open up the scanner software.

Older scanners used to feature parallel port or SCSI connections. Most new scanners connect to your computer via a USB 2.0 cable (which is also backward-compatible with USB 1.1 ports, although scans will be slower), which makes installation a simple task. However, some scanners might also have a FireWire connection for Macintosh or portable computers. Check to make sure you have a compatible connection before you purchase the scanner.

There usually isn't a huge difference in scan speeds between brands of scanners. However, if you're looking to do high-volume scans, you might want to consider a scanner that can work quickly as well as accurately.

The software bundle that ships with a scanner is another important deciding factor. Two important applications bundled with a scanner can include image editing and organizing programs and optical character recognition (OCR) software for inputting a text document to a word processor. Other extra applications may be included, such as applications that let you upload your scanned images to a website for sharing with friends and family or software that repairs and restores scratched or faded photos. Check to see how robust a bundle your scanner has to make sure it comes with all the software you will need.

Consumer scanners can be quite inexpensive, starting at well under $100. If you're a basic home user that just wants to archive your vacation pictures, you'll do fine with one of these budget flatbeds. Business users or digital photo enthusiasts might want a more expensive scanner that offers higher resolutions, a larger scanning bed or extras such as an ADF or transparency adapter. Regardless what your needsare, you can find a scanner with the format and features to meet them.




Glossary

Automatic document feeder (ADF)
A mechanical device that can feed one document after another into the scanner. This is useful for performing tasks such as faxing or optical character recognition (OCR).


Color depth
This determines how accurately a scanner can differentiate between color shades and hues. Most scanners today have at least a 36-bit color depth, or 12 bits per primary color (red, green, and blue.) More sophisticated scanners have 14 bits per color, or 42-bit color depth. Extended color depth is generally more important for photographic scanning or graphic arts work.


Film scanner
A specialized scanner that can accommodate strip film or slides. Generally, film scanners have very high optical resolution, such as 2,400dpi or greater.


Flatbed
A type of scanner with a glass platen like that of a photocopier. The document to be scanned is placed on the platen, and the scan head moves below the platen. A flatbed scanner can scan bound material such as a book or magazine.


OCR
Optical character recognition. Many scanners come with software that lets you scan a document and turn the text into text that can be edited in a word processing program.


One-touch
A scanner with one or more buttons that launch dedicated applications such as scan, fax, or copy.


Resolution
The optical resolution is how many dots--or picture elements (pixels)--per inch the scanner's sensor can image. Most scanners can also interpolate the pixels between the actual sensors to provide a higher apparent resolution. Interpolation is a statistical method, so highly interpolated images often suffer from color inaccuracies.


Sheet-fed
A type of scanner that moves the document you're scanning past a fixed scan element. Sheet-fed scanners cannot scan large documents or pages from books or magazines.


Transparency adapter
An additional light source, sometime contained in a special lid, that allows transparent media, such as slides or strip film, to be scanned on a flatbed scanner.


TWAIN
An acronym for "technology without an important name," the TWAIN driver software that comes with most scanners allows Windows applications, such as graphics software, to directly access and control the scanner.




Compare Prices on Scanners
Epson Perfection V500 Flatbed Scanner photo
The Epson Perfection V500 Photo offers extraordinary quality and versatility with 6400 dpi resolution and an earth-friendly LED light source for greater productivity — all at an amazing value. Remove dust and scratches from slides, negatives and film. Or, restore faded color photos with one touch. Then, take your photos further with the included Adobe Photoshop Elements.

Stores Selling: 23
$170.00 -
$340.00
Canon CanoScan CS8800F Flatbed Scanner photo
Sleek and fast, this powerful scanner will impress you the very first time you push power. With high-luminance white LED lamps — it's ready to scan immediately, with no warm-up time needed. You'll quickly produce spectacular results, with max. Color dpi resolution of 4800 x 9600. Seven easy buttons automate the scanning process, so it's simple to scan copy and create e-mails and multi-page PDF. Built-in FARE 3.0 retouching technology helps to enhance your final images. And to save time, you can batch-scan up to twelve 35mm frames or up to four slides — either positives or negatives.

Stores Selling: 22
$164.00 -
$301.00



  Looking for More?


Explanations

Expert Reviews
Nikon Coolscan V
Visioneer OneTouch 7300 scanner
Plustek OpticSlim M12 Plus Portable Scanner
Planon DocuPen RC800 pen scanner
Epson Perfection V350 Photo Scanner

Prices
CardScan® Executive Pass-Through Scanner
Epson Scanner Expression 10000xl Pro A3+ 2400x4800dpi Usb2.0/ Firew
Epson Perfection® V750-M PRO Film Scanner (35 mm), Flatbed Scanner
Epson Perfection® 4490 Film Scanner (35 mm), Flatbed Scanner
Hewlett Packard Scanjet G4010 Flatbed Scanner



Price Range


Family Line


Interface


Brand


Max Resolution




Narrow Your Search






ATTENTION! We recently updated our privacy policy. The changes are effective as of Thursday, October 30, 2008.

To see the new policy, click [here]. Questions? See the policy for the contact information.

Magic Debugger

release: 8.4.3-qa1
content_id: 260862
type: buyingguide
category: l4-cp-scanners

brws title: Scanner Buying Guide: Powered by ConsumerGuide and HowStuffWorks

meta d: Scanners convert photos and documents digitally. Learn about scanners in this buying guide from Consumer Guide.

url: http://shopproducts.howstuffworks.com/Hewlett-Packard-Scanjet-G4010-Flatbed-Scanner/productId=38783219