Archived Expert Review


This review is from our archive. The manufacturer has informed us that this model has been discontinued. However, it might still be available for sale. The MSRP and warranty were valid at the time the model was discontinued. We hope you'll find our other 55- to 63-inch TVs reviews and pricing useful.



Expert Review
JVC HD-58S998 Ultra Slim HD-ILA

Enlarge Image




Stores Selling:
$.00 - $.00


Expert Rating:  3  (what's this?)

Expert Review

JVC HD-58S998 Ultra Slim HD-ILA

Date Published: 4/28/08

With the popularity of flat panel TVs, many manufacturers have put their rear-projection sets on a diet. This is readily apparent with the new LCoS sets from JVC, including the HD-58S998. At just about 10.75-inches, this is as thin as they get (at least until next year, anyway). The 58-inch set from the side view almost has the appearance of a flat panel set. At 136 pounds, it is not exactly a featherweight, but is still far from monolithic.

JVC created a very nice outer casing for this set, and it makes for a handsome design. Twin front-firing direct drive speakers and a subwoofer are housed below the screen, and these do a reasonable job with the audio--they just won't replace a dedicated home theater surround sound system. More importantly, this is one of the truly wall-mounted rear-projection sets on the market today, and JVC even sells a wall-mount kit for this model. In addition, you can also choose a matching TV stand and still slide this set all the way to the wall, as the HD-58S998 features all of the primary input jacks on the side in a recessed bay rather than at the rear. This is one of those "why didn't they think of this sooner" innovations.

Tucked into the bay are the various connections you'll need to watch TV and movies. These include dual HDMI inputs, two HD component video inputs, S-Video and 3 AV inputs (one side and two in the rear), as well as PC input (15 pin D-SUB XGA/VGA). This is a nice selection of options, but it is far from overkill, and if you've have a plethora of HD devices you'll find that the set comes up a tad short--especially as some of the options are "either/or." On the plus side, the set features the VGA-computer/composite video input on the front. The downside here is that the PC input is limited to 1,024x768 resolution, which is surprisingly lacking considered the video options with many new Windows Vista PCs.

The HD-58S998 provides an extremely bright and crisp picture. The black levels are generally very good, and the set displays accurate color. Natural progressive line doubling is an option with this set, but actual results varied depending on the source materials. However, more impressive are the five video statues modes, including those for theater and gaming. On the downside the picture settings are shared across the various inputs, except for the HDMI ones. It is a minor complaint since many users probably won't take the time to make such adjustments.

The set has plenty of other options to let you get the most out of your viewing pleasure including high/low color temperature settings, video noise reduction and multiple aspect settings. The newly designed remote will put you in control, and it features full backlighting, which is still a necessary feature to have at showtime when the lights are down. This unit's remote can further take command of up to five other components.

The JVC HD-S8S998 is a great set that tries very hard to be a flat panel display. But for a price that is only a few hundred dollars more, there are reasonable alternatives in the flat panel space, which leaves this set in a difficult spot. For a few hundred less you could get a set just a few inches thicker, and for a few hundred dollars more you could get a true flat panel. This is a set that has squeezed into a very thin market, and that's as thin as it gets.


Pros: Side inputs, ultra slim cabinet, easy access to the lamp
Cons: Picture settings shared in various modes, low maximum resolution from the PC input

Warranty
1 year, parts and labor



Expert Rating Scale

 
   Value
   Is it appropriately priced?
   Performance
   How well does it work?
   Ease of Use
   How easy is it to operate?
   Features
   What's included?
   Overall
   What does Consumer Guide® think?




Product Specs

Depth
10-3/4 in.
Height
37-7/8 in.
Width
51-1/2 in.
PIP/POP
no
Nbr. of speakers
2 speakers plus subwoofer
Screen size
58 in.
Watts per channel
20 watts total
Weight
136 lbs.
Comb filter
3D Y/C
Display capability
1080p
Headphone jack
no
Parental control
yes
DVI/HDMI interface
HDMI


Compare Prices on 55- To 63-inch TVs
Samsung LN-T5781F 57 in. LCD TV photo
LCD TV, 57 inch, Resolution: 1920 x 1080 pixels, Brightness: 550 cd/m², Contrast Ratio: 500,000:1, Aspect Ratio: 16:9, 14:9 Enhan...

Stores Selling: 4
$5498.00 -
$8000.00
Panasonic TH-58PZ750U 58 in. HDTV Plasma TV photo
Plasma TV, 58 inch, HDTV Television, Resolution: 1920 x 1080 pixels, Contrast Ratio: 5,000:1, Aspect Ratio: 16:9, 4:3 Enhanced, 14...

Stores Selling: 3
$2900.00 -
$3500.00
Pioneer PDP-6010FD 60 in. HDTV Plasma TV photo
Plasma TV, 60 inch, HDTV Television, Resolution: 1920 x 1080 pixels, Aspect Ratio: 16:9, 14:9 Enhanced, Weight: 122.4 lb. (55.45 k...

Stores Selling: 3
$3399.00 -
$4000.00



  Looking for More?


Explanations

Expert Reviews
Mitsubishi WD-57734 734 Series 57-inch DLP HDTV
Mitsubishi WD-57833 1080p DLP TV
Samsung HL-T5676S DLP TV
Samsung HL61A750 61-inch DLP HDTV
Samsung HL56A650 56-inch DLP HDTV

Prices
Panasonic TH-58PH10 58 in. Plasma TV
Panasonic TH-58PZ700U 58 in. HDTV Plasma TV
LG 60PY3D 60 in. HDTV Plasma TV
Toshiba 57LX177 57 in. HDTV LCD TV
Panasonic TH-58PH10UK 58 in. Plasma TV



Price Range


Broadcast Format Displayed


Input Connector


Broadcast Format Supported


Flat Panel Type




Narrow Your Search


Price Range
Below $2850 (6)
$2850 - $3400 (6)
$3400 - $4100 (6)
$4100 - $6300 (7)
Above $6300 (7)

Broadcast Format Displayed
1080p (HDTV) (20)
1080i (HDTV) (21)

Input Connector
Composite (18)
Headphone Jack (13)
Audio (RCA) (16)
HDMI (16)
S-Video (15)

Broadcast Format Supported
1080p (HDTV) (25)
720p (HDTV) (22)
1080i (HDTV) (22)
480p (EDTV) (20)
480i (SDTV) (20)

Flat Panel Type
Plasma TV (24)
LCD TV (8)

Back to Personal Shopper






Magic Debugger

release: 8.4.3-qa1
content_id: 265795
type: review
category: l4-cp-55-to-63-inch-tvs

brws title: JVC HD-58S998 Ultra Slim HD-ILA Review: Powered by ConsumerGuide and HowStuffWorks

meta d: The JVC HD-58S998 Ultra Slim HD-ILA is the slimmest rear-projection television going. Read further in the review at Consumer Guide.

url: http://shopproducts.howstuffworks.com/Panasonic-TH-58PH10UK-58-in-Plasma-TV/SF-1/PID-43616973